Efficacy of Commonly Used Botanicals Questioned
April 26, 2004
Efficacy of Commonly Used Botanicals Questioned
SAN FRANCISCOAccording to a recent review of commonly used plant-basedmedicines in the United States, only fourgarlic, Ginkgo biloba, St. Johnswort and saw palmettoare likely to be effective based on systematic reviewsof evidence. The study was published in the April 1 issue of The AmericanJournal of Medicine (116, 7:478-85, 2004) (www.amjmed.org.).
According to researchers from the University of California, San Francisco,after a systematic review of the literature, they concluded the efficacy of mostof the ingredients was questionable. They found garlic reduced total cholesterolby 4 percent to 6 percent; ginkgo improved scores on the Alzheimers DiseaseAssessment Scale by approximately 3 percent; 56 percent of St. Johns wortsubjects responded to treatment versus 25 percent of placebo subjects; and sawpalmetto was shown to improve urinary tract symptoms and flow rates. Researchersfound no statistically significant evidence of efficacy for the remaining sixmost commonly used plant-based ingredients: echinacea, ginseng, grape seedextract, green tea, bilberry and Aloe vera.
Their findings led the researchers to call into question the efficacy ofother plant compounds. Despite the limited evidence for these 10 commonlyused [botanicals], there is likely far less or no evidence for the remainder ofthe estimated 20,000 herbal products available in the United States, wroteStephen Bent, M.D., lead author of the study.
You May Also Like